Process Capability: Cp and Cpk
A perfectly steady process can still make scrap if its natural spread doesn't fit inside the spec. compares the spec's width with the the process needs; asks the sharper question of whether it fits where the process is actually centered right now. The normal curve turns either one into parts per million out of spec.
What the symbols mean
- Process capability
Spec width over process width. It ignores where the process is centered.
- Upper spec limit
The largest value the customer accepts.
- Lower spec limit
The smallest value the customer accepts.
- Process standard deviation
Short-term spread of single parts, usually R̄/d₂ from the control chart.
What the symbols mean
- Capability where it runs
Distance from the mean to the nearer spec limit, in units of 3σ.
- Process mean
Where the process is actually centered.
- Off-center fraction
|μ − midpoint of the spec| divided by half the spec width.
What the symbols mean
- Standard normal CDF
The area to the left of z under the standard normal curve.
- Fraction out of spec
Multiply by 1,000,000 for parts per million (ppm).
Explanation
Process capability is simply a measure of whether a process's normal scatter fits comfortably inside the spec limits. The two indices are short ratios. is the room you're given (the spec width) over the room you need (about , the spread of nearly all parts). is the same idea measured from wherever the mean actually sits to the nearer limit, over . Bigger is better, and 1.33 is a common minimum. Two ratios, and a z table to turn them into scrap rates.
In control isn't the same as good. A control chart says a process is stable: the same distribution day after day. It doesn't say whether that distribution fits inside the spec. A drill that's perfectly stable but scatters holes over ±0.08 mm will never hold a ±0.05 mm tolerance, however long you chart it. Capability compares the voice of the customer (the spec width) with the voice of the process (its natural spread).
Cp: does the spread fit? A normal process puts 99.73% of its output within , a band wide. is the spec width divided by that band. At the band exactly fills the spec, and even a centered process makes 0.27% scrap (2,700 ppm). leaves a cushion on each side, so each limit is away (63 ppm when centered). Many customers require at least that, and 1.67 for safety-critical features.
Cpk: does it fit where it's running? never looks at the mean, so a process sitting right on the upper limit can boast a fine while scrapping half its output. measures the distance from the mean to the nearer limit in units of , so , with equality only when the process is centered. To see how centering enters, let be the middle of the spec and the offset as a fraction of the half-width. The nearer limit is from the mean; divide by and you get .
From an index to ppm. is a scaled distance, so it converts straight into a tail area. The nearer limit is standard deviations from the mean, so the fraction beyond it is . The two distances add up to the whole spec width, , so the far limit is standard deviations away, which gives the last form of the third formula. It's the normal-table work of Using the Normal Distribution, aimed at scrap.
What "six sigma" means. A six sigma process has its spec limits from the target: . Centered, that's ppm. Real means wander, though, so the famous figure budgets a long-term drift of . The nearer limit is then away, , and : the "3.4 defects per million" quoted everywhere.
Where σ comes from. Use the control chart's from X̄ and R Control Charts: it measures the short-term, within-subgroup variation the process is capable of. The overall standard deviation of all the data, which includes drift between subgroups, gives the long-term indices and . If the process isn't in control, neither number predicts anything, because there's no single distribution to predict from.
Cautions.
- Tail areas beyond about extrapolate the normal model. Check the shape with a probability plot before quoting 3 ppm.
- An index from 30 parts is an estimate. A χ² interval for , as in Intervals for a Mean and for Variability, turns into an interval for .
- Never use the chart's spread: single parts vary times more than subgroup means.
Fixing a poor index. Low with a good : re-center, often with a single machine offset. Low : the spread itself has to shrink, which takes engineering (a designed experiment finds the factors that drive it), or the tolerance has to widen, justified by a stack-up analysis.
See it
Worked examples
Piston pins have a diameter spec of mm. The and R charts (subgroups of 5, ) are in control with mm and mm. Find , and the ppm out of spec, and compare with the same process centered.
- 1
mm.
Practice
Type your answer and check it. Solve them all to complete the lesson.
Bolt torque on an assembly line must be between 40 and 50 N·m. The process is in control with N·m. Find to 3 significant figures.
The same torque process actually runs at a mean of 46.5 N·m. Find to 3 significant figures.
For the same process (mean 46.5 N·m, N·m, spec 40 to 50 N·m), how many parts per million are out of spec? Give 3 significant figures.
An and R chart for a valve stem diameter (subgroups of 4) is in control with mm and mm. The spec is mm. Using , find to 3 significant figures.
A process has ("six sigma"), and its mean drifts toward the upper spec limit. How many parts per million fall outside the spec? Give 3 significant figures.
A coffee packer must put at least 500 g in every bag; no upper limit matters. The filler's standard deviation is 2 g, and the customer requires using the one-sided index . (a) What's the lowest mean fill that meets it? (b) At that mean, how many bags per million are underweight? Enter both.
A capability study of 30 parts gives , computed with the sample standard deviation . Since has a distribution, the true could be larger than . Using 17.708, the value with 5% of the distribution below it, find a 95% lower confidence bound for to 3 significant figures.
A capability report shows but . What should the engineers do first?
The hardest one here. Get it, and you've got this lesson.
A bore has a spec of mm and runs in control with mm, but its mean is 20.015 mm. Engineering can afford one fix: (A) re-center the mean at 20.000 mm, or (B) keep the mean and cut by 20%. Find the ppm out of spec under each option, to 3 significant figures, entering A then B. Which option has the higher , and which makes less scrap?
Where it's used
Customers write capability into contracts: automotive and aerospace suppliers routinely have to show (often 1.67 for safety-critical features) before production is approved, and keep showing it. Engineers use capability to choose between machines, to decide whether a tolerance can be tightened and to set inspection: a feature with may need only audit checks, while one with needs 100% inspection until the process is fixed.