Vibrating Drums and Bessel Functions
A round drum is the vibrating string on a disk. Its frequencies come from the zeros of Bessel functions instead of from whole multiples of , and since those zeros aren't evenly spaced, the overtones don't line up into a clean chord. That's why a drum sounds less pitched than a string.
What the symbols mean
- Wave speed
Set by the membrane's tension and density.
What the symbols mean
- Bessel function
The radial shape of the mode; m is the number of nodal diameters.
- Bessel zero
The nth zero of J_m, so that the rim (r = R) stays still.
- Drum radius
Bigger drums vibrate more slowly.
Explanation
A Bessel function is simply the shape a round drumhead takes as you go out from its center to its rim, a wave that slowly fades, the way a sine is the shape of a vibrating string. They're named after Friedrich Bessel, an astronomer who studied them while working on planetary orbits, long before anyone used them on drums. They're good for anything round that vibrates or spreads: drums, speaker cones, heat in a pipe. All we're really saying is that a drumhead shakes in a handful of basic patterns, each with its own pitch, and the sound is a mix of them. The mode formula looks frightening, but it's three simple pieces multiplied together: (the shape going out from the center to the rim), (how the shape changes as you go around the drum) and (the up-and-down shaking in time). With (where the shape hits zero, chosen so the rim stays still), it's just the string's in round clothing, so bear with it.
Separation. Think back to the vibrating string: was forced on us because the ends couldn't move, and were the places where sine hits zero. A drum works the same way, with the rim playing the role of the ends. Write . Going once around the drum brings you back to the same spot, so periodicity forces or with integer , just like on a circular ring. The radial equation
is Bessel's equation. It looks like the Euler equation from the disk, except for the extra , and that one term is what makes its solutions oscillate. The solutions bounded at the center are , and the fixed rim requires to be a zero of . So Bessel zeros do exactly the job that did for the string.
Frequencies. Mode vibrates at . Relative to the fundamental:
| Mode | (0, 1) | (1, 1) | (2, 1) | (0, 2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.405 | 3.832 | 5.136 | 5.520 | |
| ratio | 1 | 1.593 | 2.136 | 2.295 |
Notice these aren't whole numbers, unlike a string's . Your ear hears whole-number ratios as one clear note, so drum overtones clash a little and the pitch gets muddy. Timpani makers shape the kettle and air load to pull the main modes closer to harmonic ratios.
Nodal lines. Mode has nodal diameters and nodal circles inside the rim. The diameters come from hitting zero as you go around, and the circles come from hitting zero on the way out, at the earlier Bessel zeros. It's the drum version of a string's nodes, the points of a standing wave that never move.
A common mistake. It's tempting to think the Bessel zeros are evenly spaced like the zeros of sine, because looks like a fading cosine. They're close, and the gaps settle toward further out, but not at first and never starting from 0. That small offset is exactly what keeps the frequency ratios from landing on whole numbers.
See it
Worked examples
A drum has radius 0.3 m and wave speed 100 m/s. Find its fundamental frequency in Hz.
- 1
The fundamental is the lowest mode, , so use the first zero of : rad/s.
Practice
Type your answer and check it. Solve them all to complete the lesson.
Radius 0.3 m, wave speed 100 m/s. Find the fundamental frequency in Hz.
What is the frequency ratio of mode to the fundamental?
Why don't drums sound as clearly pitched as strings?
Which ODE does the radial part satisfy?
How many nodal circles inside the rim does mode have?
A timpani drumhead has radius 0.33 m and wave speed 140 m/s. Its fundamental frequency is with . Find it, in Hz.
A string's second harmonic is exactly twice its fundamental. For a drum, the second round mode (0, 2) has frequency times the fundamental, with . Find that ratio.
The hardest one here. Get it, and you've got this lesson.
You double a drum's radius while keeping the same membrane and tension. By what factor does the fundamental frequency change? And by what factor must you change the tension to get the original pitch back? Enter both.
Where it's used
Drum and cymbal design, loudspeaker cones, microphone diaphragms, and the vibration of circular plates in engines and turbines are Bessel-mode problems.